Scary asks:
“You get a colt in for training and you find he doesn’t like to be caught. What do you do?”
I’ve been reading and asking questions about this subject for some time now. I currently own a mare who doesn’t like to be caught and the methods I have used successfully on others do not work for this one.
I know adult horses are not the same as the closer to blank slate youngster. However, I have watched short sessions of colts being started by several of the popular clinicians; Buck Brannaman, Joe walter, John Lyons, Brian Nuebert, Giwani Pony Boy, Clinton Anderson. They all seem to have the same basic philosophy about getting the horses attention and getting them "Hooked On", though with some very different techniques in getting the job done. Some of them are working cowboys, some train and compete.
I had seen John Lyons most recently when I brought home a teen aged mare from a dealers lot to use as a lesson horse. She wouldn’t be caught. I had had horses that needed to walk a short distance away from me when I came with their halters to catch them, but I had never seen anything like this mare. I created a round pen of sorts around her in the pasture where she wouldn’t be caught and I drove her away from me until I saw some licking and chewing (the signs that she is asking what she needs to do to stop being driven, like JL had directed)I backed off and turned my back on her to draw her toward me (advance / retreat—It worked). When she stopped I let her breath a brief moment and I turned and advanced towards her. When she turned her head away I drove again. I would move in and change her direction on my whim (I was told I gain respect by controlling her feet and her direction) We went on like this till she let me touch her and rub her, and then finally I would halter her and end the session. I repeated this maybe three days in a row, making the right answer (being caught) easy, and the wrong thing (turning away from my approach) difficult. After that three days. I never had to repeat the exercise with this mare. I owned her for 4 years.
The next Horse I couldn’t catch was not as easy. I used the same methods and she wore me out time and time again, We always ended with her allowing to be haltered without turning away. But it never transferred to how she behaved out side the round pen. I have resorted to cornering and bribery with her. She is not my horse now but resides with me as a boarder. I do not ride her. When I want to catch her it is to treat a boo boo, take her temperature, shoot wormer into her mouth (cornering and bribery works really fast) or to blanket her which she doesn’t mind so bribery works almost instantly. Taking the blanket off she likes so, no need for catching at all. Once when she managed to get on the wrong side of a fence from her breakfast bowl she shoved her head toward her halter before I had time enough to lift it up to her, she knew I would take her to that bucket of feed.
I have been trying to learn from the popular trainers a catching method that will always work. I haven’t figured out if there just isn’t one of if I am just not “in tune with my horse” enough to make it work. I worry that I have no sense of timing, that am never going to be able to speak the language of Equus. But, maybe there are as many methods of catching horses as there are equine personalities.
When you spend time auditing “Natural Horsemanship” clinics you will hear lots of simple sounding and yet inexplicably profound statements. “Learn to speak the language of the horse”. “ Take time to understand why the horse does what she does”. “ Let the horse teach you how to become a horseman”. “Pay attention to what happened just before what happened happened”. “Control the horses feet and you control the his mind” I am always awed at the choreographed dance that takes place in the round pen. I am encouraged by the speed at which a horse begins to comply with the handlers every wish. I become energized when I hear that I too can perform these exercises with success and enjoy the equine / human relationship I long for. After an hour in a round pen with this excercise My horse will come to me when I approach for evermore. After all, these trainers can repeat the same process over and over with horse after horse and it always works.
I come home to Lucy now who is less and less likely to be caught as the winter wears on, and fail miserably. I feel sure that I am far to blind to her language to gain her obedience or her respect. I am not clever enough to outwit nor manipulate her behavior. But maybe that's not it. Maybe I need to spend more time at it. Maybe I have to be in less of a hurry. Maybe I need to think more about me and Lucy and less about Joe trainer and some other horse.
Pony boy says I need to Study the ways of the horse. Learn her patterns, her preferences, her playfulness, and her needs. Live with her. Know her.
This is where so many of us are at a disadvantage. We don’t have hours of every day to devote to becoming a student of the horse. Yet we desire and even expect our brief allotment of time each week to groom and ride to be happy, successful, satisfying for both partys. It often doesn’t take long for something to go slightly less than perfect. We who work 45 -55 hours a week in big box somewhere oh so far away from the farm need a quick fix. We run off to another clinic, another trainer. It gets confusing. we forget the hours the months the years spent behind the trainer who makes it all look so easy. Lets see if the next trainer has a new idea that might work, we say.
Jessica Jahiel from Horse-sence.org reminds us that every horse is different. She says treats are not a bad idea and that making a horses work pleasant will increase your chances of him wanting to be caught. Always check carefully the fit of your horses tack. Be sure there is nothing painful about a work session. She also recommends the approach retreat method.
Cherry Hill advocates what she claims is the oldest time tested method of “walking down” the horse. You would start in a small space like a stall and approach when the horse stops moving away and allows contact, just scratch the horse on the wither and move away. Continue until the horse no longer leaves when you approach. Once it is working well try it in a larger space. The horse learns that you are not always going to make her work when you approach and will not feel the need to leave. Cherry remind us never to show aggravation towards the horse once caught by tugging on the halter or using harsh words. These things will teach a horse to stay away from you.
Julie Goodnight likes the “walking off” approach. She says wear comfortable walking shoes and be very matter of fact, and go right out into the pasture for this training exercise. Don’t chase, don’t corner, don’t use bribery, she says. Julie also uses the advance but retreat when the horse stops method. Turn your back on the horse drawing it in. Advance again; continue until you can halter the horse. The sessions will get shorter. There are nuances like looking at the horse as you initially advance but averting your eye as you approach after turning the horse in toward you.
So, basically it is always the same elements involved. Then why do I fail?
I started thinking about another question during my contemplations: Why would a horse want to be caught? To be taken in out of the weather? To be taken to food? To be removed from the threat of a tyrannical pasture queen? Because she's worried that you'll chase her around for an hour if she doesn't? Yes to all of the above in my experience.
Lucy wants to be caught when she knows we are going to follow her buddy somewhere. She doesn’t mind getting caught if she thinks we might be just taking a walk to a grazing spot. But there is no grazing to be had from December to April and therefore nothing that Lucy wants outside of her fence these days—she will be driven for an hour each time. She will turn and follow me when I retreat and then as soon as I move the halter toward her she is gone in a flash. Maybe motivation is everything. Maybe it has less to do with obedience.
Lately on Sunday afternoons, I am using Lucys' desire to be near me and a little bit of the advance retreat with out real pursuing. It is working so much better without the active driving part. Here is how it goes:
I will be working or doing anything not focused on her and she is sniffing me nuzzling and looking for me to rub her or blow raspberries on her nose (she just loves that). I will have the rope and halter over my shoulder. I will take it and touch her with it and then leave. I am relaxed. I am not in a hurry. (I should pay attention to that—maybe learn to be more relaxed every time I want to catch her) We will “play” some more and I will touch her with the halter or rope again, toss it over her back, rub it on her chest. Dangle the rope around her legs. This interests her. I will move away back to my “work” and she will come for more play. I will sneak the rope around her neck. She is caught. I will slip the halter over her head and snap it on. She will shake her head as if releasing tension—still it bothers her. I will leave again. I will leave her halter on for an hour. I will come back and take it off and pet her, groom her.
I think Lucy needs consistency. I now really believe that is the key. If getting haltered and getting ridden were as common to her as getting her blanket put on and taken off she would accept those things as easily too. That’s what I am planning. I’ll keep you posted.
“Allow the horse to show you who you are”. “Horses never lie” Learn how to be honest with yourself about your intensions. See yourself through your horses’ reaction to your presence. Be courageous enough to fail and try again.
And then there is This native american trick described by former stunt rider Martha Cantarini.
Recent Comments